Patriotism is Overrated

Here is my unpopular opinion for the day: Patriotism is an overrated value. Especially for Christians.

colinBefore I tell you what I mean by this, let me tell you what I don’t mean. I don’t mean that the United States doesn’t have much that is great and wonderful to offer me. I don’t mean that I wish I had been born elsewhere. I don’t mean that I hate my country, or don’t appreciate the role it has played in my having the opportunities I have. I acknowledge all that.

Here is what I do mean: As a Christian, allegiance to country is a lot less important to me than allegiance to the Kingdom shown by Jesus, a kingdom focused on love for people, not flags or anthems. I take very seriously Paul’s universal message from Galatians, that there is no longer Jew or Greek, that we are all one. It’s the same reason I don’t say the Pledge of Allegiance: because I don’t pledge the allegiance of my heart to an earthly empire. I don’t put love of country over my duty to God, which is to love other people. America first? No no, human beings first.

That is why I kneel in solidarity with black and brown America right now. Because the very same United States that has given me -a straight, white, middle class male- such wonderful opportunities, has not done so consistently for Americans of other races and nationalities throughout history. Instead, it had enslaved them, murdered them, forcibly removed them, segregated them, sought to ban them, lynched them, redlined them, arrested them, shot them, scorned them, hated them, forgotten them, made them second-class citizens, and killed them. Not as a by-product of some other goal, but as the primary goal of dealing with their existence. All the while, Old Glory was waved about and they were told it represented the very country that was oppressing them. So yeah, they probably don’t have good, positive associations about the flag.

This is why courageous powerful individuals like Colin Kaepernick kneel. For four hundred years, black, brown, and immigrant America has been trying to get the attention of white America, to get us to respect their humanity, admit our wrongs, and treat them as full human beings. They couldn’t get our attention by crying out, by marching, by sitting in, by writing, by singing, by showcasing their humanity to us. But they figured out how to get our attention, by interrupting our own gladiator games, by kneeling in front of the opium we use to ignore the injustice of the world. They got your attention. And yet you think this is about a flag, or a song. News flash: it’s not. But it was the only damn way to get your attention. Wake up America.

Patriotism is overrated because patriotism has done very little to improve the lives of the human beings who have for too long been under the heels of the powerful. And so when I say patriotism is overrated, what I mean is, I put myself on the side of my fellow human beings well before I put myself on the side of a flag. No matter what that flag has done for me. Because every advantage it brings me rings hollow as long as I know that somewhere, someone else is getting worn down by it, that my success comes at their expense and that flag tries to tell me that’s ok. Nope, it’s not. I’ll be a proud patriot when that flag admits the wrongs it has done and does real, tangible work to rectify and repair them.

That’s why I kneel in solidarity with those across the country who are sick of seeing black and brown bodies bleeding out in the street, who are sick of hearing the president defend white supremacists while calling athletes “sons of bitches.” Make me choose between the flag and other humans, and I’m gonna pick humans every time, and I don’t even feel the least bit bad about that. Jesus didn’t teach me that the greatest commandment was to love my country. It is to love my neighbor as myself.

Note: I wrote this on Facebook the other day, and get an overwhelmingly positive response. I’m happy to share it here for those I’m connected with on Facebook.


7 thoughts on “Patriotism is Overrated

  1. I rather like this. It does seem to fly in the face of the sentiments of many folks I know in my area, friends. And as a former Boy Scout trained to say the Pledge, Salute the flag, and feel alliegiance to “God and Country,” I remain somewhat perplexed as to exactly what to think of all of this.

    Nevertheless, I also posted my own opinion on Facebook, about the Black Lives Matter movement, which I think dovetails somewhat with this posting. Perhaps you might wish to take a look at it, see if you agree with my assessments?

    Liked by 1 person

  2. “For there is no authority except that which God has established.” Written by a man who would be killed by that authority because of his belief in in God. As ‘one nation under God’ it would seem contradictory then as a Christian to condemn that which He has provided.

    Of course you are a free to reject the authority of a government for its sins; however, doesn’t that also stand contrary to the Christian view of repentance? I don’t remember Christ putting limits on when or how often repentance should be given.

    In truth, if you believed for one second anything you have written, you wouldn’t commit such a self serving act as kneeling or post self aggrandizing Facebook rant. For these are little more than an attempt to build yourself up. You kneel because you aren’t like those gun toting, flag waving, probable racists. You rant to show your intellect and a braggadocios closeness to God. “The Pharisee stood up and prayed about himself: ‘God, I thank you that I am not like other men – robbers, evildoers, adulterers – or even like this tax collector….'” Luke 18:11

    If you (or the nfl players) truly want to make a difference you would actually do something. Since this whole joke started, name one person who has been set free. Name one person saved from injustice. Name one change to the country that has occurred. Are there less poor? Has African American death subsided? Is there less injustice? The kneeling and hand holding has done nothing but soothe your rich white conscience.

    In the end all you have a bunch of entitled 1%’ers living off the money supplied by their white fans who they turn around and condemn. A slap in the face to those who put their lives on the line to ensure they can perform an endzone dance. Put your money and life where your mouth (or knees) are.

    But you and I both know that won’t happen. There is no social media recognition in humility!


    1. Perhaps the very act of posting *anything* on Facebook at all is in actuality self-aggrandizing?? Is there any part of Facebook which is truly humble? And are you truly humble in pointing out this blog author’s errors? The whole thing is argument and counter-argument. No one who dares to praise or dispute some action or some opinion could be deemed humble, it would seem?

      Not sure I get what the complaint is about here.

      Lordie! I get tired of all this demonizing the demonizing demonizer schtuff!! –David


      1. Don’t bother trying David. Schmidt comments on all of my posts, rarely about the substance and more often about my motives, my right to post, or my supposed lack of real-world justice work beyond writing here. Same accusations every time.

        Liked by 1 person

  3. I think the problem is that a lot of people seem to think that being patriotic means blindly following whoever is in power and never questioning. Most people who are accused of not being patriotic are those who question what is being dome in their name or to their country. To me, being patriotic is to love your country. If you love your country, then you will question something that you perceive to be doing it (and you) harm.

    Liked by 1 person

Tell Me What You Think

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s